The Great British Bake-Off 3 – Episode 10 : The Final

And it all came down to a simple twist of fete.


1. That’s right, the end game for the Great British Bake-Off this year was a fictional fete, attended by all the eliminated contestants, who would partake in a pithivier, some fondant fancies, and a great big Showstopper Reality TV Journey cake. But we’re getting ahead of ourselves. The final challenges for our three finalists touched on the three main cornerstones of the Great British Bake Off : the savoury, the sweet, and the disgusting, dripping, oozing, slimy, inedible mess. All served up to Cathryn’s children who, let’s face it, are probably used to it by now, except at least they were being given dribbly fancies in a nice warm marquee, not over a campfire whilst their mother screamed “WHY, WHY?” as the portable burner refused to light.

2. The savoury corner of the GBBO Triangle was represented by the pithivier. No, me neither, but apparently it’s French, therefore it must be real. Frankly I’d believe almost anything was haute cuisine food if you told me it was French. Sieve some parmesan through a tramp’s sock and as long as you call it clocharde or something like that I’d buy it as an ancient gastronomic art. A pithivier, aside from an opportunity for Sue to do her best Daffy Duck impression, is apparently a puff pastry sandwich from…Pithiviers. And given that the only other thing Pithiviers is famous for is being the site of a Nazi transit camp, you can see why they’d put their name front and centre in their baked goods. Tragically, because this is the final, and everyone’s quite good, nothing terribly exciting happened. If only Sarah-Jayne were still around to make something radioactive… The most notable happening was James comparatively failing at handling a rough puff (for his chorizo and red pepper pathivier) compared to Brendan and John, who both had much more experience, leaving him with a soggy bottom and flakey, chapped sides. Write your own punchline here. Make sure to include how John drove his Italian Sausage right into the very heart of his rough puff. In the end, it was probably Brendan who won this round though, marginally. Well, at least in Brendan’s eyes, given that declared his pithiver to be “a 10/10, really, because I can’t subtract anything” about 10 MINUTES after Mary and Paul told him the sides were a bit burnt. OH BRENDAN, YOU STAR.

3. Sadly, at least for me, there was no History Bit this week. No food anthropologists, no fertility aids made out of marzipan, no stirring stories about how a Cumbrian coal-mining village was saved from destruction by a sturdily baked pork pie. I was, briefly, sad at this exclusion, but then I realised that there TOTALLY WAS A HISTORY BIT, and it was in fact a delving into the backgrounds of our three finalists. Doctor James and his Shetland island jumpers, mildly pushy girlfriend Fenella (!), and frequent jaunts to the cookery section of his university library. Gay Buddhist with a Toy Boy Brendan (<3). And most brilliantly of all, John, the law student, with a slightly disinterested flatmate ("oh yawn, another lemon curd John, HOW AMAZING, but I have to go work for a living BYE"), bantering sister ("if you win I'll be proud of you for the first time EVER, and probably not even then, HA HA") and charmingly withering mother ("frankly for the first few weeks I was hoping he'd just lose already so he could get back to doing his bloody revision like I told him to so he can get a proper job, but now that he's made the end he might as well win just so he can say he's done something with his life other than use up the entirety on the North-West's natural supply of denim"). (All words may not be literal quotes, but I feel the spirit is there). In reality terms, John's STORY came on leaps and bounds in the last episode, creating some sort of Bend It Like Beckham situation, but with baking. And he's only marginally less pretty than Parminder Nagra.

4. Let me just take this opportunity, because let's face it, there's only three people left and they axed the history bit, so I am filling like a mother, to praise the Great British Bake-Off Presenting Team. Mel, Sue, Paul and Mary, never has an hour long programme had four hosts and none of them felt superfluous. Except maybe Mel. (Just Kidding). (Mostly). (Actually I just remembered how she told off Brendan for his vaguely racist "Chelsea bunskis" so she is back in the fold). All four of them held the show together with charm and good humour, and without the camera-mugging of a Gregg Wallace. I know Steve doesn't really like Paul but…I'm recapping the final, so THERE. I love them all entire, except maybe occasionally a couple of Mary Berry's tops, let's face it.

5. SO ANYWAY. The Technical Bake. 25 Fondant Fancies. Sounds easy doesn't it? Just bake a sponge, cut it into squares, top it with buttercream, then goop it up with pink fondant. I mean, I'd rather have a go at that than a bloody teacake any day. So how heartwarming it was to see all three finalists make an utter pig's ear of it. Oh how I laughed as normally poised & perfect Brendan, slopped out fancies that frankly looked like Mr Blobby's turds. How I cackled as normally meticulously neat John had to chuck half his sponge cake away because he couldn't work out the maths. How I hugged my sofa cushion with glee when even James, who produced the best fancies of the round, was told that quite frankly it wasn't good enough at this stage of the competition. It made me immediately start plotting out my application for Great British Bake Off 4. My gimmick could be being the Bake-Offer who doesn't eat cake! It'd be like a vegetarian going on Masterchef (I think there was one of those on a couple of series ago, and I know she was VERY POPULAR)! I'd have it made! And then I remembered that my Signature Bake is a Waitrose Bacon, Mushroom & Mascarpone pizza with chorizo thrown on top, and I reconsidered.

6. And so, everything came down to the final Showstopper Challenge. To make a Reality TV Journey Cake, to represent their year and also to give a nice tear-jerker ending to the show. The eliminated contestants all lined up (most of them supporting James by the looks of it, because let's face it, it's not just the Internet Gaes that have their heads turned by an artfully revealing Aran Knit), ready to see who would win. So what heart-tugging journeys did the contestants throw into their final cakes? Well James copped out and just made 5 cakes, one for each nation-component of the British Isles, plus an extra one to represent the whole of the UK. Boring. John's "Heaven & Hell" cake was little better, with Hell representing "exams" and Heaven representing "nephews". I mean, I can appreciate trying to work the kid angle, but REALLY. It was left to Brendan, as it has been for the rest of the competition, to best represent the art of being a Reality TV Contestant, with his Gingerbread Men and almond Family Reunion cake, respresenting his desires to bring the fragmented strands of his family together. Heaven knows what foul misunderstanding could have torn Brendan's family apart. I'm guessing the end-result was somebody calling somebody "impertinent" and slapping them about the face with a lacy glove.

7. And so it was that James finished third. Probably. I mean, they never SAID, but let's be honest, he messed up every single round horribly, including the series' most rampant example of FLOORCAKE, so…he was third. In the end, he simply over-reached himself, trying to create five cakes in one baking session, and managing to come up with…one edible one. Apparently the Scottish one, which makes me think he should have just run with it and made his journey "I'M SCOTTISH!". It's on a par with "I done some exams and my sister had sex" let's be honest. It feels appropriate though that James' ultimate downfall came with his reach eventually fatally exceding his grasp, given that he's been on the verge of it for weeks now, with his haunted jizz-barn and bicycle made entirely out of treacly baguettes. Ah well, we'll always have knitwear.

8. Brendan was second, as he was always fated to be from the second that he set foot on reality tv and decided to be one of the greatest lovable villains it has EVER SEEN. At the very end, it didn't appear to be Brendan's talent that did him down, but his taste levels, which were fatally flawed, disco dips and all. That Showstopper may have tasted amazing but it looked like something Fanny Craddock would turn her nose up as being "a tad provincial". Brendan can probably console himself with having produced the two greatest moments of reality drama of the final. Firstly his prolonged gasping crying jag over NOTHING, being one of the best examples of Redemption Arc crying since Debrabarr. And secondly provoking the show's sharpest put-down of its ten-week run, from Mary Berry. "He was very good at the things he could practice at home *half-sneer*". MEOW.

9. So…John is your GREATEST BRITISH BAKER (OFFER). Meaning that the three finalists finished in exactly the opposite order to what you predicted, my readers. Well done to you all. Let's be honest, we all thought he'd lost it in the second when Paul started rampantly raking at the sides of his Hell Cake for no reason. But it turned out to be…in a good way? Anyway, the Underdog won, which can only be an appropriate ending for this most British of reality shows. Also it means he got to stick one up his mum (not like that). I feel it was a satisfying ending to a satisfying series of reality tv. Maybe now he can stop hocking around that picture of himself with his nips around everywhere. Frankly I was bored of it by the second time I saw it (and had right click-saved it to my special folder).

10. What better way to end this series than with a ranking of the American Graffitti style "And Here's What They're Doing Now!" montage that closed out the show.

11. "Peter is still trying to perfect his breadmaking" (who?)
10. "Natasha has been judging local baking competitions for charity" (and child beauty pageants?)
9. "Manisha is trying to keep up with demand for her celebration cakes" (whilst getting pissed)
8. "James passed all his exams. He spent the summer baking in a cafe" (was the air con broken?)
7. "Stuart now teaches baking as well as PE" (does he still wear shorts? That's what we want to know)
6. "Ryan is touring Europe learning as much about artisan baking as he can" (WATCH OUT SLOVAKIA!)
5. "John got a first in his law degree. He's saving up to go to Paris to train as a patissier" (So heartwarming. LIVE YOUR DREAM JOHN, LIVE YOUR DREAM *sniff*)
4. "Danny has begun writing her first article for a food magazine" (Danny got surprised by the call from the GBBO researchers and thought "shit! I've got to say something! Erm…)
3. "Sarah-Jane and Cathryn are running a market stall together" (IMAGINE!)
2. "As well as baking for local charities, Brendan is planning to teach baking in care homes" (REDEMPTION ARC COMPLETED!)
1. "Victoria has used baking to raise even more money for wild flower conservation" (EVEN.MORE.MONEY.)


27 thoughts on “The Great British Bake-Off 3 – Episode 10 : The Final

    1. Trudi Rickman

      Yes, yes he was Steve :(. My guess is that he just wasn’t going to be ‘marketable’ enough to win GBBO, and I believe that influences the decision made to a great degree. I sat there with my jaw on the floor for ages when John’s name was announced! Apart from the fact he messed up big time in the final, James was never going to win as he has steadfastly said he has no intention of taking up a career in baking, the doctoring life is his path (so what would be the point eh ;)?).

    2. FuTeffla

      So very robbed! As far as I’m concerned, Brendan should win everything ever, including the upcoming Presidential election. Imagine Brendan telling Vladimir Putin he was impertinent.

      1. monkseal Post author

        If Brendan had won, his edit wouldn’t have been the Brendan we all love, therefore we wouldn’t care enough to celebrate his not being robbed. Reality tv zen worthy of a gay Buddhist there.

  1. Connor O'Donoghue

    I’m probably not the first to go there, but: If the X Factor was made by the people who make the Great British Bake-Off, Dermot would co-present with his witty lesbian best friend and they’d make lots of smutty jokes and cake-based puns throughout the show. There would only be two judges (Gary as the Paul and Louis as the Mary) and everyone would sing three songs every week, but they’d have the good sense to edit out the boring bits and do the whole show in an hour, with no ads. The first song would be a “signature” song that the contestant has sung in the shower all their lives. The second would be the “technical” song, where they’d all have to sing the same song, but they’d only be given some of the lyrics/sheet music and they’d have to reconstruct it. The judges would have to judge this round blind, maybe on funny chairs like the Voice. The last round would be a “showstopper”: a “big” song, like “Disco Inferno”. The judges would make their decision in a nice sunny room, without much fuss, eating some cake. The whole thing would take place in a big tent with union jack bunting on a sunny summer weekend. There’s be no bloody noisy audience. No phone voting. More woodland creatures. It would be shown on the BBC and there’d be educational history segments, where a song anthropologist would take us through the story of the sea shanty, or a ballad historian would tell us about the first time Mariah sang “Hero”. I can only hope that the contestants would include a vicar’s wife and a medical student from an island who wears lovely jumpers. Now that’s a show I’d watch.

  2. catherinehirst

    I rooted for James throughout the series, but was weirdly happy that John won (perhaps because he finally swept his hair back off his face for the final and I could actually see how adorable he is – do you think he saved that as a secret weapon to subliminally influence the judges for the final?). Can’t believe you didn’t rank Cathryn and Sarah-Jane’s market stall as number 1! That could be a reality show all by itself!

    1. monkseal Post author

      I think people got a bit over-excited by that panel being accompanied by the clip of Cathryn hurling dough at (/near/nowhere near) Sarah-Jane’s face. Nobody will every be as amazing as Wildflower Conservation GODDESS Victoria. I repeat :


  3. Monaogg

    I still haven’t got over Paul not destroying Brendan’s Gingerbread House as promised by his opening comments for that challenge. 😈

    Glad John won as a big poke in the eye for a Mother who seems impossible to please and he is now doing what HE wants. Yay! 😀

  4. Verns

    Loved the GBBO; loved your two-handed blog (was Steve miffed about not blogging the final?); loved that there will be one less lawyer in the world and one more patissier; loved the kitsch bird-houses in Brendan’s garden on which he CLEARLY modelled his gingerbread house; loved the idea of Sarah-Jane and Cathryn creating mayhem on a market stall (where? where?); and loved how genuinely happy James was at not winning – what a lovely bloke.

    1. stevenperkins

      Hello! I wouldn’t say I was particularly miffed about not blogging the final – technically it would’ve been my turn to do this one if I hadn’t had to skip a week, but since this is Chris’s blog it makes far more sense for him to have the final word. Also, I don’t think I’d have had that much to say about it; I’d probably have just written “Brendan was robbed. The end.”

      When it was announced at the end that John was forsaking the law to become a patissier, I couldn’t help thinking of the agonised look on Lionel Hutz’s face that such a comment would’ve provoked.

  5. pamminxy

    I actually did go off and finally watch the whole series after last week’s blog (Brendan wasn’t at all how I pictured him but reality was even better). Then I was torn between watching the final before reading the recap or waiting for the recap then watchiing. Impatience won out.

    Brendan’s back story really got to me, I ❤ him before now it is ❤ ❤ <3. So happy to see his lovely partner, his crying and vulnerability nearly had me crying (I held it in just about as much as he did).
    Sadly his show stopper wasn't up to his usual standard (a full on Fanny Craddock meets Disney meets Disco fest would have won it for me and fitted him better) so I can't quite do Brendanwuzrobbbed but he definitely came a fitting second.

    Whoever cast the presenters deserves a pay rise, they gel perfectly and enhance the real stars (the contestants, the bakes and especially the floorcakes).

    Connor your version of X Factor would definitely get me watching! I so want it to happen (i haven't even been tempted to dip my toe in Monkseal's X Factor recap0.

    Now enquiring minds want to know what will replace GBB in blogland?

    1. monkseal Post author

      I’ve barely been tempted to actually bother writing my X Factor recaps.

      I am concerned that the blog will be a little windy next year without Apprentice Babies, and probably without The Bachelor (given the ratings). Dancing On Ice probably can’t last much longer either. What to do, what to do.

  6. G

    across the series i’d have preferred james to win, but in the last two or three episodes his nonchalance was grating on me a bit; he seems a bit like one of these people that’s pretty good at anything they turn their hand to and so it definitely seems like there was a bit of casual arrogance about his manner. john, for his sins, is at least going to man up and put on an apron for life!

    brendan’s sneaky glances during the judging and curled lip at james’ dropping cake mix were amusing but unbecoming of a meringue peddler, so i wasn’t too sad about his loss. he can flutter his HEAVILY SHADOWED pink eyelids all he wants as he tries to muster a tear…all i can think of is lindsay bluth

    1. monkseal Post author

      It’s wrong that I was satisfied by the contrast of “John got a first” and “James passed his exams” even though it certainly means SOD ALL.

  7. Megan

    I enjoyed the opening pun quite a lot.
    I am so glad John won, if only to stick it to his family. Stick it to them with cake.

  8. Jason

    Hi Steve & Chris
    This is Jason – Brendan’s partner here. Just to say that we’ve really enjoyed your posts over these last ten weeks. (You two and Katyboo1 are ahead of the game on this one). At nearly 50 I was also delighted to see myself described as a ‘toyboy’ – cheers for that. By the way, the family reunion was a great success – and the cake was a hit. Have to dash – got to keep my eye on ‘evil Brendan’! See you next year for Series Four. Jx

      1. Jason

        Must be something in the cake. Our Brendan has mystical powers that it’s best not to ask too much about.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.